Lot 40 Canadian, Second Review.

No more release year on the bottle, purchased 4/2015

Nose: vanilla, toffee, alcohol, menthol, young wood.

Palate: sharp tannins, vanilla, toffee caramels,

Finish: harsh, bitter menthol.  Hits really high and hot on the back of the tongue.

Normally, I have no intention of doing a second review... But this new bottle is way different than the 2012 release.  That stuff was great.  I loved it.  See the previous review.  This is similar.  Similar nose, but a younger feel to it.  The palate has a ton of the same notes, but is a lot sharper.  The finish on the new stuff, however, is horrible compared to the first.  I wonder if there is a lot of batch variation, or if they are just trying to capitalize on the success of that first trial of good stuff.  I went out of my way to purchase this, it isn't available in Michigan.  Really disappointed.

As I still had a sample bottle, here is a little head to head comparison...  The older has a great tobacco type note, like you went into a fine lounge where somebody had a nice pipe or cigar.  In the newer, that tobacco note feels like you went to a dive bar and somebody smoked a pack of menthols and blew the smoke at you for a couple of hours. Familial resemblance, but not the same thing.  The finish on the older is also hot and spicy, but it is a warming glow through the mouth, not the fiery belch as the newer.  Don't get me wrong, the new stuff is still pretty good, but it isn't great. It also doesn't represent the price point the way the other stuff did at all.